Miliband Disaster/Labour at War? More GB’s doing than TB’s

  • Original Home Page – And another very early post from this blog
  • Current Latest Page
  • All Contents of Site – Index
  • Sign the Ban Blair-Baiting petition here
  • Comment at end

    29th September 2010

    Click to Buy Tony Blair’s ‘A Journey’

    Two items of interest that resonate as we await the David of The Miliband will he/won’t he? announcement.

    First of all, and very interesting if true, is this at The Guardian –  [h/t here]:

    It is said that Gordon Brown rang John Prescott to urge him NOT to get behind David Miliband. This would be here (13th Sep)  pointing to here (5th Sep.)


    Gordon Brown privately intervened in the Labour leadership election by ringing Lord Prescott to try to persuade him not to put out a statement in support of David Miliband, the Guardian has learned.

    The former prime minister rang Prescott after the Ed Miliband camp heard word that he was swinging behind David Miliband. Prescott was said to be impressed with the way the shadow foreign secretary was defending Labour’s record in office over the previous 13 years.

    [See Prescott here – “The real hustings’ winner is – Labour’s record”

    But whoever is elected leader to hold the Lib Con Coalition government to account and lead our party back to Government, will need to highlight Labour’s achievements alongside their new progressive policy agenda and campaign hard to promote both.

    On this occasion, it seems the clearest defence of the Labour Government’s real achievements over 13 years came from David Miliband.

    He said: “We have to defend it with an absolute passion because if we trash our record no-one’s going to believe us in the future.”

    David has also rightly made much of the importance of greater campaigning and organisation.]

    Guardian, continued…

    The disclosure about Brown, who refused to express any preference during the leadership contest in public, came as David Miliband prepares to bow out of frontline British politics.  […]

    Concerns that Ed Miliband was dismissive of Labour’s electoral success prompted Prescott to issue a barely-coded statement supporting David Miliband. On his blog, Prescott said he supported candidates that backed Labour’s achievements in office and praised the elder Miliband.

    The Guardian also understands that consideration was given to Tony Blair and Prescott putting out a joint statement in support of David Miliband. The plan was dropped after David Miliband’s camp feared that an endorsement from the man that won Labour three elections would damage his chances of being elected due to his unpopularity with some constituency members.

    David Miliband gave a taste of his frustration at the manner of his defeat when he reacted angrily to his brother’s description of the Iraq war as wrong. The shadow foreign secretary, who has been praised for the dignified way in which he accepted defeat, chided Harriet Harman for clapping his brother’s description of the war as wrong. Harman, in common with David Miliband, voted in favour of the war in 2003. With a thunderous look on his face, as he listened to his brother’s speech, the older Miliband could be seen saying to Harman: “You voted for it. Why are you clapping?” With a fixed smile on her face Harman responded with the words: “I am clapping because, as you know, I am supporting him.” The exchange, picked up by an ITN camera trained on David Miliband during his brother’s entire speech, came after the new Labour leader delivered an unequivocal declaration about the war.

    “I do believe that we were wrong. Wrong to take Britain to war and we need to be honest about that,” he said. “Wrong because that war was not a last resort, because we did not build sufficient alliances and because we undermined the United Nations. America has drawn a line under Iraq and so must we.”

    The brief outburst by David Miliband showed his acute sensitivity about one aspect of the Labour leadership contest where he believes his brother behaved in a disingenuous way. Ed Miliband said early on during the contest that the Iraq war had been a mistake. David Miliband slapped down his brother in July by saying that Diane Abbott was the only leadership candidate who could credibly claim to have opposed the war. Ed Miliband, who was teaching in the US at the time of the war, insisted he had opposed military action at the time.

    Aides to David Miliband were relaxed last night that his private frustration over his brother’s handling of Iraq had come into the open. “That’s what he thinks,” one friend said.


    Who is SAID to have said of Ed Miliband – “a disaster in waiting”?

    This was at the Herald Scotland and has been virally copied elsewhere since, in the usual way. I always prefer to find an authoritative source for quotes, and I haven’t found other than quotes of quotes on this one.

    But, just so you know, it is SAID that TONY BLAIR (remember him?) said that Ed Miliband is “a disaster-in-waiting”. I’ve checked through ‘A Journey’, and although Mr Blair mentions Ed Miliband several times, he doesn’t actually say anything all that detrimental about Ed M, except to make it clear that he thought of the two Eds (Balls and Miliband) as firmly in Brown’s camp in the TB/GBs struggle.

    Herald Scotland: “Mandelson said Ed Miliband’s leadership would lead Labour into an electoral cul-de-sac. Alan Johnston, the former home secretary, was more explicit. He said Ed would split the party and would keep it out of power for “many years”. Blair is said to have branded Ed a “disaster-in-waiting”.

    Yet despite the attacks, Edward Samuel Miliband, 40, son of the late Marxist intellectual, Ralph Miliband, and an MP for only five years, this morning finds himself at the head of a party he has been a member of since he was 17, with most expecting him to lead a head-on war with the Conservative-led coalition all the way till the next election in 2015.”

    Well, we waited, and the disaster’s upon us.

    [Thanks to Tom Carew here at Facebook for reminding me of this.]

    Back to top

    Related Articles

    Click to Buy Tony Blair’s ‘A Journey’


    Sign the Ban Blair-Baiting petition here

    Recent comments:

    “Mr. Blair is one of the finest politicians to have had the priviledge of serving the United Kingdom, and Britons are fortunate to have had him as their Prime Minister. Time will show that Mr. Blair’s approach to affairs in the Middle East were and remain correct. From a member of the Commonwealth, thank you, Mr. Blair, for your continued service to legitimate and lasting (and not convenient or politically expedient) freedom.”

    AND – “Tony Blair was the greatest Prime Minister since Winston Churchill and the only regret I have he didn’t get my vote as I live in Canada.”

    AND – “I am sick and tired of television and radio interviewers asking the same old questions over and over, regarding the decision to go to war in Iraq, presumably they hope Mr Blair will let slip some secret information which they would then use against him. History will show if the decision was the right one, (I believe it was) but people must accept that Tony Blair is a honourable man, and made his decision based on the known facts and not with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight.”

    Free Hit Counter


    Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

    2 Responses to “Miliband Disaster/Labour at War? More GB’s doing than TB’s”

    1. Peter Reynolds Says:

      “Well, there’s a fine mess you’ve got me in.”

      Was that Stan to Olly or Olly to Stan…or Dave to Ed or Ed to John or Tony to Olly? I don’t know. Seems like a pretty good summary though.

      Ed went down in my estimation immediately I read of his Harriet Harman connection. She and Alan Johnson leave a foul taste in my mouth.

      Interesting article in The Herald.

      I’m more than happy to see a new broom in EdM. I think he’ll try to be his own man. He’ll try to shed all the baggage and forge his own path. It’ll be interesting to see what happens. I wish him well because I do believe that a strong opposition is a good thing. Did I tell you that my eldest son’s best friend was part of EdM’s campaign team? On the nod, nod, wink, wink, they say Ed is way to the right of David. So we’ll see!

      Just saw fantastic documentary on BBC2 – Secret Iraq. You should watch it if you missed it. I am sure The Box will have it tomorrow.

      • keeptonyblairforpm Says:

        Blast! I meant to watch the Secret Iraq programme. Went right out of my head. Out all day tomorrow. Will see if I can find it elsewhere. I don’t expect it was kind to TB, though, being the BBC.

        Anyone who is against the Iraq war is bad news as far as I am concerned. Ed M is bad news.

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


    Connecting to %s